Score: 94Vintage 2020Vinous MediaThe 2020 Malbec J Alberto is a Malbec with a 5% dash of Merlot from an old vineyard first planted in 1935 in Mainqué, Río Negro. Half aged in cement and 600 liter barrels, the rest was kept in stainless steel. Bright purple in the glass, fresh cherries are intertwined in the nose with violets, black tea and hints of country herbs as part of a substantial but delicate profile. The aging process plays a supporting role but offers no more than a faint whiff of orange petit fours. On the palate, the balance is precise with delicate weights and measures in which the flow is lean and releases an energy toward the end that fades entropically like a wind-up toy. An elegant wine.Shelf TalkerFull Page Review
Score: 94Vintage 2019James SucklingWonderful depth here with blackberries, blueberries and iodine, as well as oyster shell. The aromas change all the time. Full-bodied, layered and polished with lovely length. Drink or hold.Shelf TalkerFull Page Review
Score: 93Vintage 2019VinousA field blend of Malbec with 5% Merlot, planted in 1955 in Mainque, Río Negro, up to 40% of which was fermented in whole bunches. Aged in new and used barrels with no sulfites added until the end. Bright violet in hue, this is a fragrant red with aromas of cherry and red currant and hints of spice, herbs and stalk. Corseted on the palate, it presents gentle but angular tannins that lend depth and character to the fluid feel and the sharp, fruity flavor. The spine is provided by freshness, which stretches out the lengthy finish. The best J. Alberto I’ve had in years.Shelf TalkerFull Page Review
Score: 91Vintage 2018VinousThe nose presents bread and chocolate aromas plus ripe plum, raisins and spice. Slightly liqueurish on the palate, it is full of flavor, fluid and smooth with a terse texture, a juicy feel and delicate freshness.Shelf TalkerFull Page Review